Fox News is once again in the spotlight, but this time, it’s not for a major scoop or breaking news story. Instead, the network is making waves with behind-the-scenes chatter about a potential shakeup on its flagship talk show, The Five. As the show continues to dominate cable TV with an impressive average of 3.851 million viewers in Q2 2025, the whispers of change have captured the attention of both fans and industry insiders alike. Sources suggest that former Democratic Congressman and rotating liberal co-host Harold Ford Jr. could be replacing Jessica Tarlov as a permanent fixture on The Five.

The speculation began to gain traction after reports emerged in late August 2025, citing that Ford, with his calm demeanor and political pedigree, was being considered for a permanent spot on the panel. Ford, known for his thoughtful commentary and measured approach to debate, could offer Fox News a different direction, particularly as the network looks to broaden its appeal in today’s increasingly polarized media landscape.

A Bold Move or Risky Shift?

As rumors swirl about Ford potentially replacing Tarlov, the conversation has ignited intense debate, particularly on social media platforms. On X (formerly Twitter), the news sparked a wave of reactions. While some fans applauded the idea of Ford’s more composed approach, calling it a “bold power shift,” others feared it could upset the delicate balance that has made The Five a ratings juggernaut.

“I think Harold Ford Jr. is classier than Jessica Tarlov,” one user commented, praising Ford’s more refined style. On the other side, another tweet argued, “Jessica’s the spark. Replacing her is a disaster.” The passionate debate underscores just how important Tarlov’s role has been in the show’s dynamic since she joined in 2022. As the liberal voice on the panel, she has often been at the center of fiery debates, earning both acclaim and criticism for her unapologetic positions.

Tarlov’s Tensions and Ford’s Appeal

Jessica Tarlov has drawn a mixed response from The Five’s audience. Approximately 20% of the show’s viewership identifies as Democratic, and Tarlov’s vocal liberal perspective has resonated with this segment, making her a key part of the show’s appeal. However, her on-air clashes, especially with conservative co-hosts like Jesse Watters, have not been without controversy. One such incident—a widely discussed confrontation with Watters—was described by sources as a “wrecking ball” moment, where the tension between the two hosts seemed to spill over, raising concerns about on-air discord.

Ford, in contrast, is seen by some as the perfect foil to the high-octane debates that often dominate the show. Known for his calm and respectful style, Ford could be the stabilizing force that helps Fox News navigate the political divides of today’s media landscape. Industry insiders speculate that Ford’s background and demeanor would offer a more balanced approach to discussions, which may help to moderate the tone of the show while still appealing to a broad audience.

The Ratings Gamble

Ford’s potential appointment comes at a pivotal moment for Fox News. The Five has proven to be a ratings success, regularly outpacing other cable news shows in terms of viewership. The show’s success is largely attributed to its format, which features a rotating panel of commentators with differing political views. It’s a formula that has resonated with viewers, offering an engaging mix of analysis, debate, and humor. However, with ratings continuing to climb, could this be the perfect time for Fox News to make a strategic move that would redefine the show?

According to reports, Fox News is in the midst of a massive $2 billion strategy to challenge legacy networks and diversify its programming. Part of this overhaul, analysts believe, could include a shift in the tone and makeup of the The Five panel. Ford’s potential appointment could be a signal that the network is trying to capture a broader audience while maintaining its conservative base.

The Future of The Five and Fox News Prime-Time

As the rumors continue to swirl, all eyes are on Fox News to see how this potential shakeup plays out. Would Ford’s more measured approach be enough to maintain the momentum that The Five has built over the years, or would it risk alienating viewers who have grown accustomed to Tarlov’s fiery and direct style?

Tarlov, for her part, has not publicly commented on the rumors, and there has been no official announcement from Fox News regarding her departure from the show. She remains a co-host for now, and her influence continues to be felt on The Five‘s discussions. Still, the speculation surrounding her role and the possibility of Ford stepping into a permanent position has created an air of uncertainty about the future of the show.

Fox’s $2 billion strategy is clearly a long-term play, and The Five is a key part of its programming. If Ford does take over the role permanently, it could signal a broader shift in prime-time programming, as Fox looks to fine-tune its appeal to a wider range of viewers.

Will Ford’s Style Win Over Viewers?

Harold Ford Jr.’s reputation as a calm, measured voice may be exactly what Fox News needs to balance out the heat of partisan debates. However, as the reactions to the rumored change demonstrate, not all viewers are convinced that this shift is necessary or beneficial. Ford’s political pedigree and respectful nature have earned him praise on Reddit threads, where users describe him as a stabilizing presence in a sea of fiery rhetoric.

But The Five’s strength has always been in its diversity of voices, and Tarlov’s unique approach as a liberal force has undeniably added to the show’s dynamic. Whether or not Ford can successfully replace her and maintain the show’s winning formula remains to be seen.

A Broader Shift at Fox News?

The potential change on The Five is indicative of larger trends at play within Fox News. With its $2 billion strategy underway, the network is clearly focused on evolving and adapting to the changing media environment. The success of The Five has been key to Fox News’ continued dominance in cable news, and the stakes are high as the network attempts to reshape its programming. The decision to possibly bring in Ford as a permanent replacement for Tarlov could be part of a broader move to bring a more balanced and nuanced approach to prime-time coverage.

As the story continues to unfold, fans and industry observers alike are watching closely to see what direction Fox News takes. Will the network continue with its tried-and-true formula, or will it pivot to something entirely new? Regardless of the outcome, one thing is certain: the drama surrounding The Five and its potential shakeup has become one of the most captivating stories in cable television this year.