In a shocking and unexpected twist, NBC is reportedly exploring the possibility of replacing a beloved Today Show host, sending ripples of excitement and concern through the morning news community. With Today show ratings facing increased pressure from both streaming platforms and niche outlets, NBC executives are eyeing a significant move to reshape the show’s lineup. But which host might be at risk, and what does this mean for the future of America’s iconic morning program?

The Today Show Shake-Up: What’s Really Going On?

For years, the Today show has been a staple of morning television, with familiar faces like Hoda Kotb, Jenna Bush Hager, and Savannah Guthrie at the helm. But recent developments have sparked rumors and speculation. In January 2025, Hoda Kotb stepped down from her role as co-anchor, leaving a noticeable void in the show’s dynamic. While Craig Melvin stepped in to fill one of the co-anchor seats alongside Savannah Guthrie, the departure of Kotb has left many wondering: what’s next for the show, and could there be more changes coming?

NBC has yet to confirm anything officially, but insiders suggest that the network is quietly considering a major shake-up. According to reports, NBC is exploring the possibility of bringing in a big name, potentially an A-list celebrity, to fill the empty spot. This bold move would inject star power into the show, boosting ratings and drawing more viewers to the Today franchise.

Who’s on the Short List for a Potential Co-Host Spot?

While NBC has been tight-lipped about specific candidates, sources close to the situation have offered a glimpse into the possible replacements. Among the rumored names are some of Hollywood’s biggest stars, as well as some rising talents from within the NBC family.

Scarlett Johansson: The popular actress, known for her role in the Avengers franchise, has reportedly impressed NBC executives with her guest-hosting stints on Today. Her immense pop culture appeal and wide fanbase make her a natural contender for the spot, and her star power could be exactly what NBC needs to boost ratings.

Savannah Guthrie: While Savannah already plays a central role on Today, some insiders believe she could move into a more prominent co-hosting position. This would offer a smooth transition, as Savannah’s chemistry with Jenna Bush Hager has been well-received by viewers.

Justin Sylvester: A rising star at Today, Justin has demonstrated strong chemistry with Jenna Bush Hager during their on-air segments. His engaging personality and relatable presence make him a strong contender for the co-anchor spot.

Sheinelle Jones: The fan-favorite co-host has been a regular presence on Today for years. Her rapport with the audience and her charisma make her a natural fit for the role, and some sources suggest that NBC may be considering Sheinelle as a permanent solution to the show’s co-host dilemma.

Matt Rogers: A fresh and exciting comedic voice, Matt Rogers has impressed audiences with his quick wit and on-camera charisma. His ability to inject humor into the show could be just what the Today show needs to stand out in an increasingly competitive morning news landscape.

Why Is NBC Making This Move?

The decision to explore a potential co-host replacement comes at a time of heightened pressure for Today. Traditional morning viewership is in decline, with audiences increasingly turning to streaming services and niche news outlets. In response, NBC has been aggressive in reshuffling its lineup, hoping to capture the attention of a new generation of viewers.

The shake-up follows a pattern of bold moves from NBC in recent years. For example, the network’s hiring of Megyn Kelly in 2017 was a significant, though controversial, attempt to boost ratings and bring in a fresh perspective. While Kelly’s time on Today was short-lived, it signaled NBC’s willingness to take risks in order to stay competitive.

Now, the network is reportedly focusing on finding a host who can provide not only a ratings boost but also the right chemistry with Jenna Bush Hager. The dynamic between co-hosts is crucial to the Today show’s success, and NBC is prioritizing a natural, seamless pairing that will resonate with the audience.

Fan Reactions: A Mix of Excitement and Uncertainty

As rumors swirl about the possible replacement, fans of the Today show have been vocal in their reactions. On social media, hashtags like #TodayCoHostShakeup and #ScarlettOnToday have gone viral, with fans speculating about who might join Jenna Bush Hager on the show.

Some fans have expressed excitement at the possibility of Scarlett Johansson joining the team, while others have voiced support for Sheinelle Jones, who has been a fan favorite for years. There are also those who want a more unexpected choice, seeking someone with fresh energy and new ideas to inject into the show.

Despite the excitement, many fans have also expressed concern about the potential impact of such a major change. The Today show has built a loyal fanbase over decades, and any disruption to the familiar format could risk alienating viewers. The chemistry between Jenna and her co-hosts has been a defining factor of the show’s success, and fans worry that any new addition might disrupt the balance.

What NBC Is Watching Closely: Ratings and Chemistry

NBC executives are closely monitoring a variety of factors as they consider who should replace Hoda Kotb. Ratings, of course, are a major consideration. The network is evaluating how guest-hosting stints from stars like Scarlett Johansson and Matt Rogers impact viewership. They’re also tracking social media engagement to see how fans react to the potential co-hosts.

Chemistry between co-hosts is another key factor in the decision-making process. As Hoda Kotb’s departure showed, the Today show thrives on the camaraderie between its anchors. NBC is keenly aware of how important it is for Jenna to have a co-host who not only brings star power but also the right energy to complement her style.

What’s Next for the Today Show?

While NBC has yet to confirm any details, fans can expect a decision soon. With the summer fast approaching, NBC may look to make an official announcement about the new co-host before the season changes. Until then, speculation will continue to swirl as viewers eagerly anticipate the big reveal.

In the meantime, Today continues to adjust to the shifting dynamics of morning television. Whether they choose to go with a celebrity co-host or a rising star from within the NBC family, the future of the show remains uncertain but exciting.

Conclusion: NBC’s Bold Gamble

As NBC continues to grapple with declining morning show ratings and the departure of a major figure, the network is taking a bold step by exploring potential co-host replacements for Today. Whether the network opts for a big name like Scarlett Johansson or an in-house star like Sheinelle Jones, the decision will have a major impact on the show’s future.

Fans are anxiously awaiting the announcement, knowing that the choice of co-host could signal a new era for the beloved morning program. One thing is certain: with a lineup shake-up in the works, the Today show is about to take a daring leap forward—whether fans are ready for it or not.