With Hoda Kotb’s Emotional Exit Looming, TODAY Show Faces Huge Shake-Up—Who Should Join Jenna Bush Hager as Permanent 4th Hour Cohost? Fans Demand Their Voices Be Heard—Poll Goes Viral as Surprising Names Top the List! Will NBC Listen to the People?

The TODAY Show is facing one of its biggest shake-ups in recent history as beloved cohost Hoda Kotb’s emotional and potentially final departure looms on the horizon. After years of uplifting mornings, heartfelt interviews, and iconic chemistry with Jenna Bush Hager, Hoda’s rumored exit has left fans stunned, saddened, and eager to know what’s next for the cherished 4th hour of TODAY.

And in classic 21st-century fashion, the people are speaking—loud and clear—on social media and in a now-viral poll calling for NBC to include the audience in one of the most important casting decisions in morning television.

Is Hoda Kotb Leaving the TODAY Show for Good?

Hoda’s reduced on-air presence and recent focus on family, particularly after her daughter Hope’s highly publicized medical battle, has fueled speculation about her long-term plans. While Hoda has not made an official statement, multiple insiders and media outlets have suggested that her full-time return is unlikely.

“She’s prioritizing her family,” a source close to the anchor revealed. “She’s not walking away from the spotlight forever, but daily live television may not fit into her life anymore.”

And with that potential shift, attention now turns to the million-dollar question: Who should sit beside Jenna Bush Hager on the fourth hour of TODAY?

The Viral Poll That Took the Internet by Storm

As fans grieved the idea of a Kotb-less TODAY, a Twitter poll started by a longtime viewer quickly gained traction. Within 24 hours, it had over 100,000 votes and thousands of comments—all suggesting replacements ranging from household names to unexpected newcomers.

The viral post read:

“With Hoda Kotb likely stepping away from TODAY’s 4th hour, who should join Jenna Bush Hager permanently? NBC, we need to be part of this decision!”

The poll featured five trending names, but fan write-ins made it clear: the audience has opinions—and they’re not afraid to share them.

Top Contenders to Join Jenna on the 4th Hour

Let’s break down the most-mentioned names from the fan poll and online buzz:

1. Savannah Guthrie

A familiar face and TODAY veteran, many fans feel Savannah could slide seamlessly into the seat next to Jenna. Her gravitas, warmth, and experience are undeniable—but would she leave her prime TODAY role for the lighter tone of the 4th hour?

Fan Quote:
“Savannah brings both brains and heart—she could totally switch gears and have fun with Jenna!”

2. Carson Daly

A longtime TODAY family member, Carson is already part of the team and brings a relaxed, conversational energy. His chemistry with both Jenna and Hoda has always been natural.

Fan Quote:
“Carson and Jenna would be hilarious together! Real talk, real laughs.”

3. Jenna’s Sister, Barbara Bush

This wildcard entry shocked many—but also intrigued. The idea of real-life sisters sharing that couch gives off cozy, relatable energy. Barbara, though less known in media, has a calming, articulate presence.

Fan Quote:
“Sisters cohosting? It would be authentic, warm, and refreshing!”

4. Michelle Williams (Actress & Author)

A surprising but popular write-in after her viral audiobook narration and thoughtful interviews, Michelle’s poised demeanor and introspective nature could balance Jenna’s bubbly charm.

Fan Quote:
“She’s elegant, wise, and unexpected. The show could take on a deeper tone with Michelle.”

5. Maria Shriver

A Bush family connection and television veteran, Maria Shriver was one of the most requested names. Her experience in journalism, advocacy, and storytelling makes her a powerhouse candidate.

Fan Quote:
“Maria brings legacy, experience, and purpose. She and Jenna would be phenomenal.”

The Fans Speak: What They Want in a Cohost

Across platforms, common themes emerged in the thousands of comments and hashtags:

Chemistry is key: Viewers want someone who complements Jenna’s style—not overpowers it.
Authenticity matters: The audience is craving genuine, honest conversations—not just entertainment.
Laughter with heart: A balance of humor, depth, and real-life storytelling is the winning formula.

“Jenna’s emotional openness and sense of fun are what make the 4th hour special. Whoever joins her needs to match that energy—but also bring something new,” one fan wrote.

NBC’s Challenge: Tradition vs. Transformation

NBC executives now face a difficult choice: Stick with a familiar face from within the NBC family, or shake things up with a bold new voice?

Sources say that internal testing, screen tests, and viewer focus groups are already underway, and fan feedback is playing a larger role than ever before.

“This isn’t just about filling a seat,” a production insider revealed. “It’s about protecting the soul of a show that fans feel deeply connected to.”

There are even rumors that NBC may rotate guest hosts over the summer, using live feedback and ratings to help determine the permanent choice—similar to how Jeopardy! handled its post-Trebek era.

Jenna Bush Hager’s Reaction

Jenna has remained mostly quiet amid the speculation, but during a recent segment, she acknowledged the outpouring of love for Hoda and teased that “change is coming.”

“I’m excited and a little nervous about what’s next,” she said with a smile. “But I know one thing: This show is built on friendship, laughter, and truth—and that’s not changing.”

What’s Next for Hoda Kotb?

While she hasn’t confirmed a full departure, Hoda’s recent focus has shifted toward motherhood, health advocacy, and writing. She has reportedly signed a new book deal and is working on a project centered around resilience and parenting through hardship.

“I’ve been through some hard things recently,” Hoda shared in an interview. “But they’ve brought me closer to my children and to myself.”

Some believe she’ll return in a more limited capacity—perhaps for special interviews, holiday segments, or even a podcast series hosted under the TODAY brand.

The Power of Audience Voices

With social media polls trending and fan suggestions going viral, NBC is under pressure to listen to the audience like never before. The people who tune in each morning aren’t just viewers—they’re part of the TODAY family.

And they want a seat at the table.

“We’ve laughed with Hoda, cried with her, and healed with her,” one long-time viewer tweeted. “Whoever follows her has huge shoes to fill—and we deserve a say.”

Conclusion: A New Chapter Begins

Hoda Kotb’s possible departure from the 4th hour of TODAY marks the end of a deeply personal and beloved era. But with change comes opportunity—a chance to reimagine the format, highlight new voices, and create magic once again.

As NBC weighs its options, one thing is clear: fans want authenticity, chemistry, and a host who brings both joy and depth to their mornings.

Whether it’s a sister duo, a seasoned journalist, or a surprise newcomer, the world is watching—and waiting—to see who will sit beside Jenna Bush Hager and carry the legacy forward.

NBC, are you listening?

SEO Keywords:

Hoda Kotb leaving TODAY show
TODAY show 4th hour new cohost
Jenna Bush Hager new partner
NBC morning show shake-up
Who replaces Hoda Kotb
TODAY show fan poll cohost
Hoda Kotb exit news 2025
Top choices for TODAY show 4th hour
Viral poll TODAY show cohost
Jenna Bush and new cohost 2025

Want me to turn this into a shorter script for a video, social caption, or press release version?