John Foster, the smooth-voiced country crooner who stole hearts on American Idol Season 23, is now teasing fans with the possibility of his next big move — and it might just include sequins and the spotlight of the Dancing With The Stars ballroom.

The 18-year-old Louisiana native and college student finished runner-up to Jamal Roberts, but his popularity continues to soar. With a growing fan base and a viral debut single, fans are now wondering: Is John Foster headed to the dance floor?

John Responds: “It’s Certainly Not a No”

In a recent interview with TV Insider, John was asked directly about the possibility of joining DWTS — and while it wasn’t a confirmation, it definitely wasn’t a hard no either.

“I never really thought about that,” he said with a grin. “But I’ll tell you this — it’s certainly not a no.”

That simple response sent fans into a frenzy online, with many picturing the country heartthrob taking on the cha-cha or foxtrot in front of millions.

His Heart Is Still in the Music

While the idea of ballroom stardom is fun to imagine, John is staying laser-focused on his first love: country music. His current single, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” is a deeply emotional tribute to his late friend Maggie Dunn — and he’s determined to share its message far and wide.

“I wrote that song by myself,” he shared. “It’s personal. I think it gives people a real glimpse of who I am as an artist and songwriter.”

He’s also hard at work on his debut album, enjoying time in the studio while staying connected to the raw emotion that defines his sound.

And after months of traveling for the show, there’s something else on his mind, too:

“I’ve missed my dog a lot,” John laughed. “I can’t wait to go home and just unwind for a little while.”

Could DWTS Be a Smart Career Move?

There’s no doubt that Dancing With The Stars would elevate John’s visibility and attract a broader fan base — especially among mainstream TV audiences. But the show also demands intense rehearsal schedules, weeks of competition, and major time commitments.

That could clash with the critical momentum John has right now in country music — building on Idol exposure, recording new material, and possibly planning a tour.

Other Idol Alums Have Done It — With Great Success

If John does decide to join DWTS, he’d be in good company:

Kellie Pickler (Season 5 finalist) went on to win Season 16 of DWTS.

Lauren Alaina (Season 10 runner-up) made it to the final four.

Jordin Sparks (Season 6 winner) brought elegance and charm to the ballroom.

With Foster’s stage presence, charisma, and rhythm (as seen during his unforgettable “Jailhouse Rock” performance), he could absolutely follow in their footsteps — when the time is right.

For Now: The Focus Is the Music

As exciting as a reality TV pivot might be, now appears to be the perfect time for John Foster to pour everything into his craft. With emotional depth, storytelling power, and a voice that resonates far beyond Idol, country music is where he truly shines.

At just 18, the door to television will still be open — but the heart of a true country artist beats strongest when surrounded by lyrics, steel guitars, and fans who feel every word.