The billion-dollar success of “Barbie” almost had a completely different face at its center. While Margot Robbie captivated audiences worldwide, insiders have revealed that Blake Lively was secretly in serious talks to step into the iconic role. However, what could have been a dream casting quickly turned into a behind-the-scenes dispute, leading to Blake being completely shut out of the project. The shocking reason why has finally come to light.

Blake Lively’s Near Casting and the Fallout

Blake’s previous work alongside America Ferrera in “The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants” made her a natural connection to the “Barbie” universe. Her glamorous fashionista image, blonde hair, and picture-perfect smile seemed tailor-made for the film’s vibrant aesthetic. Additionally, the film’s team aimed to celebrate actresses from iconic female ensembles, making Blake appear to be a logical choice. However, something went terribly wrong during negotiations.

Sources close to production reveal that Blake wasn’t satisfied with simply being one of many Barbies in the ensemble cast. While stars like Issa Rae, Dua Lipa, and Hari Nef embraced the collective vision Greta Gerwig and Margot Robbie had crafted, Blake reportedly pushed for something more. She allegedly sought a standout role, creative input, and even attempted to reshape her character into something more prominent than originally envisioned.

This wasn’t just about screen time. Insiders claim Blake wanted influence over the character’s development, storyline, and even aspects of the script. This approach clashed with the project’s ethos, which emphasized collaboration and collective power rather than individual stardom. Greta Gerwig’s vision, backed by Margot Robbie’s production company, LuckyChap Entertainment, was to create a cohesive and diverse ensemble, not a film centered around a single star’s demands.

Margot Robbie’s Role in the Decision

Unlike Blake, Margot Robbie took a different approach. As the producer of “Barbie,” she played a crucial role in shaping the project but remained open to stepping aside if needed.

“I didn’t actually audition for the role of Barbie. I produced the film, so I guess I cast myself,” Margot later revealed. “I made it very clear to Greta that I didn’t have to be in the movie. I was happy just to produce. But she said, ‘No, I really want to write this for you.’ And she wrote me an amazing part, so I’m very grateful.”

This level of humility and collaboration stood in stark contrast to Blake’s reported demands. The last thing Margot wanted was an actress trying to reshape the film’s structure before cameras even started rolling. When Blake pushed for more creative control, insiders claim Margot quietly closed the door, ensuring the film remained aligned with its original vision.

The Industry’s Reaction to Blake’s Approach

Interestingly, Blake’s attempt to exert influence over “Barbie” wasn’t an isolated incident. Reports suggest similar tensions emerged on the set of “It Ends With Us,” where she allegedly made significant script changes and attempted to reshape the narrative around her character. This reportedly led to friction with director Justin Baldoni, who was also co-starring in the film.

Additionally, Blake’s professional relationships with former co-stars have raised eyebrows. Anna Kendrick, who worked with Blake on “A Simple Favor,” has reportedly requested solo interviews for the sequel and limited joint appearances. When asked about working with Blake again, Anna’s responses have been noticeably reserved. Even America Ferrera, once closely linked to Blake, has remained publicly silent about her former co-star for years.

The Contrast Between Blake Lively and Margot Robbie

The difference in how Blake Lively and Margot Robbie navigate Hollywood power is striking. Margot has built her influence by producing projects from the ground up, earning respect through collaboration and vision. Her production company has backed acclaimed films like “Promising Young Woman” and has maintained strong industry relationships.

Blake, on the other hand, seems to seek influence by reshaping existing projects to her advantage—a strategy that appears to be backfiring. Instead of trusting directors and producers, she allegedly looks for opportunities to position herself in the driver’s seat, regardless of how it impacts the overall vision. While ambition isn’t inherently negative, the way she reportedly pursues it has raised concerns within the industry.

The Bigger Picture

Blake’s exclusion from “Barbie” wasn’t just about missing a role in a blockbuster film. It signaled deeper concerns about her Hollywood standing. With “It Ends With Us” facing controversy and her reputation taking hits, the question remains: will Blake adjust her approach, or will more industry figures follow Margot Robbie’s lead in keeping her at a distance?

As “Barbie” continues to break records, it’s clear that Margot’s decision paid off. The film thrived without Blake, proving that sometimes, knowing who shouldn’t be on set is just as important as choosing who should be. For Margot, the film’s enormous success is a testament to her collaborative leadership—a victory that speaks louder than any behind-the-scenes drama ever could.