In an emotional moment rarely seen on daytime television, beloved host Drew Carey pleaded with The Price Is Right producers to reconsider one of the show’s most frustrating games. The heartfelt plea has stirred fan discussion across social media and reminded viewers of the human side of competitive entertainment.

Drew Carey, who took over the legendary show after Bob Barker’s retirement, has long been praised for his lighthearted humor and deep care for contestants. But during a recent episode, Carey showed a more serious side when a contestant failed to win a prize in the notoriously difficult game “That’s Too Much.”

The episode featured a contestant named Ismail, who was visibly excited about the chance to win a brand new SUV. The objective of “That’s Too Much” is to identify the price that goes just over the actual retail price of the car. Sounds simple — but in reality, it’s anything but.

Ismail was doing well until a moment of confusion struck. After making his selection, he initially said, “I’ll stay right there,” before quickly correcting himself with the required phrase, “That’s too much.” Unfortunately, the rules of the game don’t allow for mistakes — and he lost the car.

Carey, clearly moved by the incident, turned to the camera and addressed both the audience and the production team:
“We really should change the name of the game. Maybe to ‘Stay Right There’ or ‘No More.’ People just don’t naturally say ‘That’s Too Much.’”

His comments drew cheers and nods of agreement from the audience. It was a rare moment of vulnerability and sincerity on a show typically filled with cheers and celebration.

Fans online echoed Carey’s sentiments. One user wrote:
“That game is just cruel. So many contestants lose just because they don’t say the magic words. It’s time for a change.”

Another added:
“Drew Carey is such a kind soul. You can tell he really cares about the contestants. That moment made me tear up.”

The Price Is Right has long featured a variety of mini-games — some beloved, others controversial. Among the more difficult ones, fans frequently mention Lucky Seven, Stack the Deck, and Time Is Money as sources of frustration. However, That’s Too Much consistently tops the list of games viewers say should be retired or revamped.

Over the years, Carey has taken a more active role in advocating for changes to the show’s format. Though ultimately, final decisions rest with the producers, moments like these show just how invested he is in the contestant experience.

Despite the loss, Ismail remained in good spirits and thanked Drew for the support. The audience gave him a standing ovation, and the emotional tension on set served as a reminder of just how high the stakes feel — even for a daytime game show.

So far, there’s been no official word from CBS or the show’s producers regarding Carey’s suggestion. But with fan support growing, it may only be a matter of time before That’s Too Much gets a much-needed overhaul — or even a complete retirement.

As viewers continue to root for everyday contestants to take home big prizes, Drew Carey remains a pillar of empathy and good-natured fun. And in moments like this, it’s clear: he’s not just hosting the show — he’s fighting for its heart.

What do you think? Should “That’s Too Much” be renamed or retired entirely? Share your thoughts in the comments and stay tuned for more updates from behind the scenes of your favorite game shows!