Browns Owner Stunned by Shedeur Sanders’ Practice Performance: Calls for Immediate Start

1. Setting the Scene

Cleveland Browns owner Jimmy Haslam has reportedly been left “shocked” after watching rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders in practice, to the point where he allegedly demanded that the coaching staff start Sanders immediately. The incident has sparked widespread discussion among NFL insiders and fans alike, raising questions about whether Haslam is trying to fast-track a rookie QB or if his reaction is more symbolic than operational.

2. Haslam’s History and Connection with Sanders

Jimmy Haslam is known for his hands-on approach with the Browns, occasionally intervening in football decisions. According to sports analyst Colin Cowherd, Haslam is eager for a star player, and in his eyes, Shedeur Sanders represents a high-potential talent. However, Haslam maintains that drafting Sanders was GM Andrew Berry’s decision, and that starting quarterback choices ultimately rest with Head Coach Kevin Stefanski.

3. The Practice That Shocked Haslam

Sources indicate that Haslam closely monitored Sanders’ practice sessions. While many expected the rookie to be gradually eased in, Sanders reportedly impressed with his passing accuracy, decision-making, and confidence on the field. Observers claim that Haslam repeatedly nodded, murmured to himself, and instructed his staff, “Start him now.” The intensity of Sanders’ performance seems to have ignited Haslam’s belief that the rookie could immediately contribute to the team’s success.

4. Internal Pushback

Despite Haslam’s enthusiasm, Browns’ coaching staff has reportedly expressed caution. Coach Stefanski is believed to be weighing the long-term development of Sanders against the pressure to win. Some insiders suggest that Haslam’s urging could create friction if Sanders struggles on the field, as the coaching staff would bear much of the responsibility.

5. Haslam’s Public Statements

In a media session, Haslam emphasized the need for improvement after a disappointing 3‑14 season. He acknowledged Sanders’ potential and stated that both Sanders and quarterback Desmond Gabriel would have opportunities to play, but reiterated that starting decisions lie with the coaching staff. This delicate balance highlights Haslam’s desire to see immediate results while not officially overstepping his authority.

6. Sanders’ Potential

Shedeur Sanders, son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, comes from an HBCU background and was drafted in the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft. Despite dropping lower than expected, analysts believe Sanders’ football IQ, leadership, and field vision make him a valuable asset. During practices, insiders note that Sanders exhibits maturity and composure, which contributed to Haslam’s enthusiastic reaction.

7. Risks and Challenges

Fast-tracking a rookie quarterback comes with significant risks. If Sanders struggles, it could impact team morale, coaching credibility, and the rookie’s confidence. Moreover, the dynamics between Haslam, Berry, and Stefanski could become tense if the owner is perceived as meddling excessively in operational decisions.

8. External Opinions

Analysts like Colin Cowherd argue that Haslam’s push for Sanders is partly motivated by the player’s narrative and media appeal. However, some commentators caution that rushing a rookie into a starting role could backfire if the team isn’t prepared to support him fully.

9. Possible Outcomes

If Sanders succeeds as a starter, the Browns could gain a new franchise quarterback and energize their fan base. On the other hand, if the experiment fails, it could lead to internal discord and stall Sanders’ development. The optimal scenario seems to be a balanced approach: giving Sanders opportunities while managing expectations and providing mentorship.

10. Conclusion

Jimmy Haslam’s reaction to Shedeur Sanders’ practice performance has captured the attention of the NFL world. While the owner’s enthusiasm is clear, the decision to start a rookie quarterback involves complex dynamics between management, coaching, and player readiness. Whether this move becomes a bold success or a cautionary tale remains to be seen—but one thing is certain: all eyes are on Shedeur Sanders and the Browns as they navigate this pivotal moment in their season.