Blake Lively’s Co-Star Isabella Ferrer CAUGHT LYING About Justin Baldoni?!

The It Ends With Us drama has taken yet another turn — this time involving Blake Lively’s co-star Isabella Ferrer. Once seen as an uninvolved young actress who wanted to steer clear of the escalating legal chaos, Ferrer is now being accused of backtracking and aligning with Blake’s narrative against director and co-star Justin Baldoni.

How Isabella Ferrer Got Pulled In

Blake Lively's Co-Star Isabella Ferrer CAUGHT LYING About Justin Baldoni?!

When It Ends With Us was filmed, Ferrer played the younger version of Blake Lively’s character, Lily. She and Baldoni never shared scenes together, but their names are now intertwined thanks to the lawsuit fallout.

Blake Lively originally brought Ferrer into the conversation by alleging that Justin Baldoni acted inappropriately during a young Lily love scene. That claim, though, was never confirmed by Ferrer herself. In fact, text messages revealed by Baldoni showed the opposite: Ferrer had praised him, calling him “a wonderful, smart, sincere director” who created “a comfortable, safe space” on set.

Those glowing words seemed to clear Baldoni of misconduct in her eyes. But now, Ferrer’s lawyers are painting a different picture.

The New Filing: Harassment or Just a Subpoena?

Through her attorneys, Ferrer recently argued that Baldoni is “harassing” her by drawing her deeper into litigation with subpoenas. But here’s the problem: subpoenas are a standard part of legal discovery, not harassment. Baldoni’s team simply wants access to Ferrer’s communications and testimony — especially given her direct connection to Blake and her earlier positive comments about him.

This legal strategy has left many observers baffled. If Ferrer complied with subpoenas from Blake’s side, why not do the same for Baldoni’s? The double standard has sparked speculation that Ferrer’s legal team may be stalling on purpose.

The Indemnity Clause Drama

One twist involves Ferrer’s contract indemnity clause, which she argues should cover her legal expenses in dealing with subpoenas. Normally, such clauses apply when an actor is personally sued — not when they are a third-party witness. Baldoni’s side has reportedly offered to cover her under Wayfair’s insurance representation, but Ferrer pushed back, creating a stalemate that now fuels the claim of harassment.

Legal experts note this move could backfire. Subpoenas can’t simply be ignored, and resisting them risks contempt of court.

The Blake Lively Connection

Blake Lively VS Justin Baldoni: It Ends With Us Star Isabela Ferrer Accuses  Actor Of Explicit Comments, Financial Bribe | Bollywood Bubble

Critics believe Ferrer’s new stance has Blake Lively’s fingerprints all over it. The language in the filing mirrors Blake’s ongoing arguments against Baldoni — framing him as manipulative and threatening. Observers suspect Ferrer may have been influenced or pressured into siding with Blake and Ryan Reynolds, whose Hollywood power could heavily impact Ferrer’s young career.

The optics are difficult for Ferrer. By shifting from praising Baldoni to labeling his legal team “harassing,” she risks being seen as inconsistent — or worse, dishonest.

Fans React: Sympathy Turning Into Frustration

Initially, many supported Ferrer as a young actress caught in a storm not of her making. But the latest filing has sparked criticism. Fans question why Ferrer, who once thanked Baldoni for creating a safe environment, is now portraying him as harassing her simply for seeking testimony.

Popcorn Planet host Andy Signor summed up the growing frustration: “She needs to pick a lane. Either stand proudly with Blake and say something happened, or tell the truth and clear Justin. Evading only makes things worse.”

Even supporters caution that Ferrer’s legal team may be giving her bad advice, making her appear evasive when she could have resolved the issue by simply complying with the subpoena.

A Dangerous Position

The stakes are high. If Ferrer continues to resist, she risks damaging her credibility in Hollywood. If she flips again, she may anger Blake’s powerful circle. Either way, her reputation is now entangled in a scandal she initially tried to avoid.

For Justin Baldoni, Ferrer’s shifting stance adds another complication to his fight to clear his name. For Blake Lively, it’s another chance to reinforce her narrative against him. And for Isabella Ferrer, the decision to fight subpoenas rather than comply may prove to be the most dangerous move of all.